Except that the Mike Tyson of 1990 was not the same man who dominated the 80s. Not because he was past his prime, he was still very young. But he had lost and fired the coaching team who turned him into the best, quickest, most technical heavyweight ever, become addicted to drugs, had let fame go to his head, surrounded himself with Yes Men, didn't train for the fight, lost focus, lost discipline and lost his killer instinct. So watching this shell of his normal, great self, lose to someone who didn't even deserve a shot was really more of a sad disappointment than a classic upset.
The following year, Mike was supposed to fight a more-than-worthy opponent in Evander Holyfield but he ended up spending the next few years in prison for sexual assault, making his meteoric fall from grace even sadder. We saw some flashes of the old Iron Mike after he was released on 1995, but he was never the same. What makes this even worse is that while the heavyweight division was lacking some overall talent in the 80s, many great heavyweights emerged in the 90s. It would have been great to see the “Tyson that could have been” fight all of those guys in their prime.
But even without Tyson, the 90s would see a resurgence of a solid, heavyweight division more competitive than in just about any other era of boxing. Holyfield, Riddick Bowe, Lennox Lewis, Michael Moorer and even Big George Foreman came back against all odds to hold the title for a minute. There were heavy hitters like David Tua, Tommy Morrison, Razor Ruddock and Ray Mercer who kept things interesting too.
The 90s also gave us much more relevant fighters in the other weight divisions. Oscar de la Hoya, Pernell Whitaker, Felix Trinidad, James Toney, Julian Jackson, Ricardo Lopez (maybe not a household name in the US but never lost a fight in the minimum weight division), Chris Eubank, Prince Naseem Hamed and probably the greatest boxer of the decade, Roy Jones Jr. Honorable mentions include Michael Carbajal, Stephen Collins, Terry Norris, Michael Nunn, and Johnny Tapia.
We also had guys like Julio Cesar Chavez and Hector Camacho whose best years may have been in the 80s but still continued to perform in the 90s (especially Chavez, who was still very relevant and unbeaten for much of the decade), as well as future superstars like Bernard Hopkins, Floyd Mayweather Jr. and Vitali Klitschko, whose careers would really take off in the following decade but got their starts in the 90s.
You could take those all those names and put those up against ANY decade's greats and honestly, the 90s probably beats them all in terms of just sheer number of stars. Sure, none of them shone as brightly as a Ali or Sugar Ray Leonard or even Mike Tyson but I don't think it can be argued that there was more overall talent in multiple weight classes than in any other era of boxing ever.
So the 90s were awesome then, right? Yeah. I guess they were. But somehow I don't feel the way I think I should about the decade. Maybe it's just a personal thing because of what happened to Mike Tyson's career, in addition to other boxing heroes I grew up with in the 80s fading out? Maybe it's because I was finally an adult and spent more time partying than being captivated by boxing? Or maybe I just didn't have the same connections with any of the fighters, no matter how good they were?
I can certainly acknowledge that Lennox Lewis was a truly, all-time great boxer, good finisher, and a nice, charismatic dude but I never once really enjoyed watching his fights. I was always bored for some reason. Exact same thing with Oscar de la Hoya. And Pernell Whitaker certainly did some amazing stuff in the ring defensively but I can't say I love watching him like so many other boxing purists. Roy Jones Jr. was a different story. He brought excitement and a level of athleticism to boxing that we hadn't quite seen yet. He wasn't as compelling of a sports personality as the other legends but was a dominant force for the entire 90s and into the 00s in several different weight divisions.
There were some good fights in the 90s though. The trilogy of Holyfield and Bowe being at the top of the list. The first bout between Chris Eubank and Nigel Benn is a classic too and will always be one of my favorites. The decade also welcomed in the first, true era of WOMEN'S professional boxing. There had been female amateur fighters for over a hundred years but there certainly wasn't a whole lot of it. Women did not compete in the Olympics, in Golden Gloves or any other significant competition. By the very late 80s, a few professional fighters started to emerge with very little exposure. That would change on March 16, 1996, when the Mike Tyson-Frank Bruno II fight had the top female fighter at the time, Christy Martin, vs. Deidre Gogerty on the undercard. This would be the first time most of us saw women box and while the fight itself doesn't showcase the greatest of technique, it was a total bloodfest and got national attention. Christy would make the cover of Sports Illustrated and is considered the pioneer of the sport.Another important footnote to the decade that might explain some of my slight ambivalence is that something else happened in the 1990s to steal a bit of boxing's thunder - Mixed Martial Arts. The UFC debuted in 1993 and while the production value and level of talent was nowhere near what it is now, we were seeing different martial arts compete against each other for the first time. I found it very compelling and it got me interested in some of those martial arts, particularly the ones we as a society were not really familiar with at the time like Brazilian (Gracie) Jiu-Jitsu and Muay Thai, In fact, this was how I got started in combat sports, which certainly took some of my personal interest away from boxing. Boxing was the old thing, mixed martial arts was the new thing. It would take about another 10 years before the UFC finally broke through into mainstream recognition but it was very much born in the 90s and continues to pull a percentage of the audience away from boxing. I myself ended up coming full circle, getting back into boxing and now finding MMA a little boring by comparison.One more far less important footnote about the 90s: left (lead) hooks. Maybe I'm grasping at straws but I think it is fair to say that collectively, that decade gave us some of the best left hooks ever. It was the signature punch by three of the greatest 90s fighters - Oscar de la Hoya, Roy Jones Jr. and Evander Holyfield. While he wasn't one of the greatest, Tommy Morrison's left hook was pretty legendary. David Tua had some highlight reel lead hook knockouts as well. Felix Trinidad and Ricardo Lopez were good at pretty much everything but finished plenty of their fights this way too.
A final thing I want to say about the decade is that I took for granted was the commentary and presentation of boxing fights on HBO/HBO ppv, where most of the big ones took place. Jim Lampley, Larry Merchant and sometimes George Foreman made a great broadcasting team. In fights like Felix Trinidad vs. Oscar de la Hoya, we actually saw the judges scores round by round and it made things much more interesting. There is, to me, a very big difference in how boxing was presented then vs. how it is now. I feel like it attempted to better engage a wide audience of varying levels of interest whereas boxing presentations today are seemingly only aimed at the niche boxing fans, with no real attempt to reach any broader.
So to answer my own question, YES boxing was indeed better in the 90s. It certainly helped that there were so many great fighters but there is some pretty significant talent right now too. Boxing has experienced a little bit of resurgence in terms of cultural relevance and I find many of the divisions more interesting than they been in the last couple decades (00s and 10s). I just wish it were promoted and presented more like it was back in the day and we could bring in some new fans. One great thing about the modern day is that we can at least watch all of these classic fights on YouTube so even if you weren't alive to see any of those classic 90s boxers during their heyday, it is all just a keystroke away!